For me, Its the roles. I mean its a frickin cowboy game and we cant even have cows or own property besides the moonshine shack(but were really just renting it), we cant fish off boats the animation is in the game but they just dont implement it. No stores to rob, no trains to rob. we also need a dueling mode where you and one person can actually duel, we need a trapper role, a fisherman role, miner role and etc. we need to tame wild horses, and survive bear attacks instead of just dying. so basically everything you can do in story mode they should implement in online.
Yeah, i defo want rdr3 to happen, i dont want rdr2 to turn into gta and gta o, where the games been out for almost a decade and no updates for story mode, also i want rdr2 online to die, in a way where if the game has turned into a wild west gta, people would stop playing it so rockstar knows we arnt playing around.
For combat
Mauser Pistol
Mauser Pistol
Litchfield Repeater
Carcano Rifle
Machete or Broken Pirate sword
Throwing Knife
For Hunting
Lowrys Revolver
Bolt Action or Bow
Varmint Rifle
Hunting Knife or antler Knife
Lasso