What are some of your predictions for Butchers creek’s growth and development, particularly during Jack Marstons adventures. I’m curious to see if people think it would have turned into a small town or settlement or if it falls into ruin due to the iron poisoning in the towns river.
4,668
pages
ALL POSTS
All posts by Raphael Supertrampe
@ArthuMorga your accusation that I’m associated with a user that’s been banned for a long time is a little baseless. I mean sorry I made a joke, my man.
@ArthuMorga What exactly have I done wrong? I haven’t defended anyone.
@ArthuMorga , @TTunion is already banned
I actually like him, too. I wish we saw more of him because in my opinion- nobody is irredeemable, yet Rockstar deliberately only shows bad points of him to make him hatable. It’s almost like hand holding. “You shouldn't like this guy.” I don’t think that’s good writing, as far as villains go, he’s really menacing, but not well written, and I think we need to admit that.
The same way Micah haters have to admit that, canonically, there were times when Arthur ate stew and laughed around a campfire with Micah, and Micah taught Jack something during his 6 months with the gang.
Human beings are complex animals, and so is Micah. We just aren’t SHOWN many good points to him, if any, and I don’t like that about RDR2.
(Edited by Raphael Supertrampe)
Damn. When @TTunion , that super handsome guy who’s not here anymore, mentions hating Sadie his account gets banned and he has to make an alt account- but when this guy says it everyone’s fine with it. 🥶
Am I the only one who thinks we should let the pre established characters lay where we’ve left them? I don’t wanna go digging up Dutches past or Colms past. Just seems like we’ve seen the perfect amount of each character.
@Leprechaunlauch When Lyle dies at the end you play as Copper in the epilogue.
Lotta edgy kids in this thread
Just walk to the Van Horn stable and recall
It there
As in, suggestions or actual weapons we have?
John’s outfit is simply too iconic not to win.
I don’t think so, since the gunsmith seems to imply he watched his son die. However it’s more likely than I realized prior to reading the post. Gunshot would and an abandoned child, presumed dead. Good theory and it definitely got me thinking it’s possible.
*watched his son by drowning, not gunshot wound, I was mistaken*
(Edited by Raphael Supertrampe)
For Arthur, his animal spirit is an eagle (in my opinion, since it’s the good karma animal.)
From my understanding, it’s always gotta start at the Saint Denis postal shop. If there’s no marker on your map, look for letters you have in your satchel or mailbox. Read each of them, looking for “business proposal” or “letter from Cripps.” See if a mission spawns at that specific post office.
“Raphtir” on ps4
That’s right. You should friend me and we can RP together
You role play?
I suppose I always had the hopeful (and most likely false) idea that foiling the mining companies plans during the stranger mission somehow leads to a future in which mining is stopped due to them not wanting to be liable for the butchers creek illness and then their water supply naturally recovers.
I pride myself knowing everything there is to know about the game but I will never in a million years understand how dueling works.
(Edited by Raphael Supertrampe)