There are a lot of good choices in here. but i went with trelawny. for one he is not used much in the main story. and for two i don't even know if i saw him and john interact. i don't think they are in any missions together. so it would be cool to see them meet and talk.
Uncle easily. i know a lot of people liked him and thought he was funny. but to me he is super annoying and cringey. every time i play a mission he is in i try to rush through it. he was much better in rdr1 with a better actor and personality. but in rdr2 he is a joke. and the lumbago memes are pretty boring too.
I always wondered this too. i think it would have been cool to have a scene where john finds a phone and calls them. it would be cool to see john use one.
Sorry only colonel daren has a cannon sidearm. although it would be cool if you could get one.
I cant live without either the semi auto pistol or the mauser. they are my favorite guns in the series.
Blackwater for sure. i never was a huge fan of it in rdr1. and it looks even worse in the second. plus i just dont like how they did the old map. its just not as good as the original. and thats why i always try to stay in the new map. because its the best part.