If you wanna be treated well by bandits wear the bandito outfit and you can keep the good honor
Poncho plus El Senor mule in Mexico and no one calls you gringo, try it
Definitely between armadillo and thieves landing for me but thieves landing makes things half price if you choose bad honor where everywhere else its double price so thieves landing for me but apart from that armidillo
Would have chose Chuparosa but its lacking a gunsmith so Escalera for me
Manzan cuz it has everything you could ever want in one condensed area, has safehouse, stagecoach taxi (which some other small towns don't), a general store that is almost a gunsmith store and dr shop all in one, plus a place to play five finger fillet along with a newspaper spot and bounty post
But to be fair in the whole rdr1 map blackwater is second best
Nastas cuz he was killed by his own brainwashed people
I chose rebels because as john himself puts it "he's barley worth a bullet"
Evans just has so much ammo capacity so less reloading