I imagine this question gets asked a few times. sorry

Today I was walking at Horseshoe Overlook when I saw John speaking at the main campfire. As I never saw him telling stories, singing or speaking his thoughts and feelings, I decided to get closer and listen.

John told the gang members not to pick up a woman, because they would only get in trouble if they did. He expresses a hatred, anger and resentment towards Abigail. In the end, John adds that if he could kill her, he would. Arthur asked if things with Abigail were going well, and John told Arthur not to interfere in his life.

It's been a long time since I saw a RDR1 gameplay, so to confirm my thoughts, I accessed the dialogues from the mission "Bear One Another's Burdens".

Edgar Ross says:

"We've done this little deal for your freedom in exchange for all the men from your old gang. You gave us Williamson and Escuella. We still don't have Dutch van der Linde, but now we know where he is."

This means that Ross kidnapped John's wife and son so that John would hunt down his former gang members, when the Bureau of Investigation barely knew where all the members were. Also, I don't remember if Javier's prison was necessary for Abigail and Jack's release. So the deal was only for Bill's capture, because they didn't know where Dutch was and Javier might not even be considered.

On August 18th, 2011, 16:13, a user by the name of LyHungViet made an edit to the Blackwater page. This is what he added:

"The city has also been the site of a bloody gunfight dubbed the "Blackwater Massacre" of 1899. The massacre was apparently a bloody gunfight involving Landon Ricketts, who was the only known survivor of the incident. Some 22 outlaws and 15 lawmen are said to have perished during the battle."

Here's his activity on the Blackwater Page:

https://reddead.fandom.com/wiki/Special:Contributions/LyHungViet?target=LyHungViet&offset=20111026121907&limit=500

Now, the RedDeadFandomWiki back in the day was essentially factual information mixed in with fanfiction, and perhaps this is one of those cases. However, LyHungViet does not appear to be the type of user who would've added false information to a page.

This brings me to my question: How did LyHungViet know that the Blackwater Massacre was outlaws vs lawmen long before RDR2?

The newspapers in RDR1 only ever talk about the Blackwater Massacre when it concerns Landon Ricketts. The newspapers never talk about what caused the massacre or what the body count was.

LyHungViet, appears to have often hung around NPCs to get dialogue from them. Could it be possible that this is where the information came from?

Does anyone want to help with exploring this mysery?

It's been a while since I've played it, and I want to 100% it. Any tips?

So I’m playing undead nightmare on the new rdr1 switch version. Recently certain towns will become lost out of nowhere. I’ll start the game and they’ll be safe then when I play a little they just become lost. The weird thing is when I leave and rejoin they are safe again and the process continues. It also is specifically manzanita and armadillo. It seems like a glitch but I was wondering if anyone else is running into the same problem or have a explanation/way to fix it?

Does anyone still play? I believe that RDR1 will always be good and never get old, but what do you guys think?

the article claims Helaku is the Native American that John needs to kill in order to survey Dutch's camp, but it also claims that he is alive in "You will know the Truth" and "The Truth Will Set You Free"

Seeing as PS4 is all I have and at $50 with the DLC, I think it's a great deal. I've been wanting to play RDR1 again for a long time.

Weird request, but would someone who has RDR be able to send me/reply with photos of the interior? There's no good photos online and I don't have the game. Thank y'all!

How would you feel about if Jack got a dlc to show us what happened to him after the first game and lead up to his death.

Jack’s fate after killing Agent Ross is unknown, and there are many theories, which is why I want to know what you think happened.

I, personally, think that Jack Marston fled the law (possibly into Mexico) after killing Ross, and he would be known as one of the last gunslingers of the west, especially since the era actually known as the old west ended twenty years prior. Knowing Jack didn’t follow his father’s (or Arthur’s) advice to live a normal life, which seems like a curse, he probably won’t get a good ending. I speculate that Jack is caught by the United States Government and hung by the end of the decade. Optimistically, Jack could lay low and maybe flee the continent, but I think thats unlikely. Others think he may have joined WWI, which idrk about. What do y’all think?

So if you play arthur as high honor but plays john in low honor

Do any dialogue changed if you play johns as low honor

Right after you get high honor ending

Im not talking about low honor ending

I was wondering if you do evil things as johns after

You get high honor ending as arthur

Do any dialogue changed

If you honor goes down as johns???

Cus i never played the games before

Just asking about???

The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed is done ride into Blackwater to purchase the last scrap of the US Army Uniform, go to purchase from the newspaper when I can’t even buy the final newspaper!

Hello since most of the character include amos and bonnie mcfarlane appeared in rdr2 online

I just wondering if rockstar add more character from rdr1 include west dickens and sheriff leigh johnson

So here is list

Norman deek (rdr1)

Eli and jonah - one of the johnson's boys

Vincente de santa

Abraham reyes

Nastas

Agustin allende or allende

Harold mcdougal

Alwyn Lioyd aka welsh

Leander holland aka french

(Whas you opinion about???)

On of the dogs in armadillo spent at least a whole 5 minutes following me. I decided to call the little treasure Bob.

Thoughts?