A Fisher of Fish

A Fisher of Fish is a Stranger mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. The quest becomes available after completion of the mission "A Fisher of Men".

Story[]

Part I[]

Jeremy Gill, a self-proclaimed legendary fisherman, is found fishing off the dock. After he is approached, he asks if the player is interested in an autograph or photograph before leading them inside his cabin to show off his livelihood - selling stuffed fishes. He gives the player a map of all Legendary Fish sites in the world and says he'll pay a handsome price for any that are sent his way.

The required fish are:

These three cannot be fished until the Epilogue:

The Legendary Northern Pike is not part of this mission.

Once all thirteen fish have been mailed to Jeremy, an invite to his cabin will be received in the mail.

Part II[]

Jeremy tells the player to help him on a fishing adventure: to catch a giant catfish in Río Bravo. Upon arriving, Jeremy tells the player to photograph him landing the fish. An entire day passes fishing. Finally, at night, Jeremy gets a bite and fights the fish vigorously, but is pulled into the water and is never seen again. His hat and Special Spinner can be picked up by the player.

Rewards[]

1 Legendary Fish Mailed - Lake Lure.
10 Legendary Fish Mailed - $45 and Succulent Fish Meat (X5).
13 Legendary Fish Mailed - Invitation from Jeremy Gill.

Missable Items in the Mission[]

Fisherman's Hat

Trivia[]

As some legendary fishes' habitat are in New Austin and in the south-western parts of West Elizabeth, the player will only be able to finish this mission after reaching the epilogue.
The title of the mission is likely a reference to "A Fisher of Men", a story mission in Red Dead Redemption 2.