Butler is a resident of the city of Saint Denis where he runs a store for fruits and vegetables on the market of the city.
Events of Red Dead Redemption 2
His store becomes available to the player after the mission "Eastward Bound". He offers a large assortment of fruits and vegetables, though the player can only buy carrots and apples off him.
- Butlers appearance is random, though each of his character models have a mustache and wear a vest.
- Due to his store not being of a specific type (like a General Store), it is not marked on the map.
- On the outside of his store there is a sign saying "Alexander Butler & Son" while under the store's roof another sign saying "A. Butler & Bro. - Dealer in Fruit and Vegetables" can be seen.
- His store is present in Red Dead Online, though no goods can be seen for sale and Butler is nowhere to be found.