He can usually be found in and around the ArmadilloSaloon, usually drinking or loitering with other members of Walton's Gang. If the player assaults the Twin Rockshideout, Alfie, along with Perry Rose (Cooper Reed in Free Roam), will fire at him/her from the top of the rocks.
Scruggs can also be seen in a couple of random encounters. First, he and other gang members will be pursuing a fleeing stagecoach. If the player chooses to intervene and kill the coach drivers, Scruggs will personally thank them before the outlaws drive off with their prize. The second encounter involves Scruggs and other bandits forcing a supply wagon driver to hand over his goods on the side of the road. The player can earn Honor if they come to the aid of the robbery victim.
Events of Undead Nightmare
In Undead Nightmare, Alfie can be found defending the settlement of Twin Rocks alongside Dale Chesson and Rufus Higbee, where he is on the roof of the middle building. If Twin Rocks is saved and Alfie survives, he will stand around the firepit with the other survivors.
He is one of the few criminals to say "hello," or "greetings," to both NPCs and Marston in Armadillo. He also engages in conversations with other civilian NPCs though Alfie himself does not have any conversational quotes, only greetings, responses, and a conversation ending and farewell quote each.
Alfie appears in the mission "The Sport of Kings, and Liars" as a contestant in the race. If he is killed, the mission will automatically fail, and he will not count as a Walton's Gang death.
During the Twin Rocks hideout in Free Roam, Alfie has taken Perry Rose's place on the left rock and Cooper Reed has taken his place on the right rock.
Alfie leads the "Supply Run" random encounter for Walton's Gang, which can be anywhere in the general Cholla Springs area. He will also usually be in charge of the "Fate of the Stagecoach" random encounter, assuming he holds a higher position in the gang.
Alfie has a small scar that cuts across his left eyebrow, which is more easily visible when he does not have his hat on.