He can usually be found in and around the Saloon at Armadillo, hanging around other members of Walton's Gang. During the Twin Rocksgang hideout, Alfie, along with Perry Rose (Cooper Reed in Free Roam), is one of the outlaws on top of the large rocks.
Him and Perry Rose will also be the leaders of the "fate of the stagecoach" random encounter concerning Walton's gang and he will thank the player if the latter chooses to help them.
Events of Undead Nightmare
In Undead Nightmare, Alfie can be found defending the settlement of Twin Rocks alongside Dale Chesson and Rufus Higbee, where he is on the roof of the middle building. If Twin Rocks is saved and Alfie survives, he will stand around the firepit with the other survivors.
He and Woody Swenson are the only members of Walton's gang who don't appear as a Bounty Target.
He is one of the few criminals to say "hello," or "greetings," to both NPCs and Marston in Armadillo. He also engages in conversations with other civilian NPC's though Alfie himself does not have any conversation quotes, only greetings, responses, and a conversation ending and farewell quote each.
Alfie appears in the mission "The Sport of Kings, and Liars", in which he is a racer. If killed, the mission will fail and he will not count as a Walton's Gang kill.
During the Twin Rocks hideout in Free Roam, Alfie has taken Perry Rose's place on the left rock and Cooper Reed has taken his place on the right rock.
Alfie leads the "Supply Run" random encounter for the Walton's Gang, which can be anywhere near roads in the general Cholla Springs area. He will also usually be in charge of the "Fate of the Stagecoach" random encounter, assuming he holds a higher position in the gang.
Alfie has a small scar that cuts across his left eyebrow that is more easily visible when he does not have his hat on.
