Chick Mathews is a farm worker who has failed to pay back his loan to Leopold Strauss.
Events of Red Dead Redemption 2
When Arthur arrives at Guthrie Farm, he will be seen grooming his horse. Arthur asks a ranch worker where he can find Matthews and the ranch worker will point out Matthews. Chick Mathews is seen fleeing on his horse.
Arthur will have to chase after him and lasso him off his horse. Matthews will beg Arthur to let him go, and will give him a map of where he stashed his debt money. He will run away after giving Arthur the map.
- Killing Chick Matthews will lower the player's honor.
- If Chick is greeted before the other farmhand, he will play dumb and tell the player to ask the farmhand for help. However, if the player aims a weapon at him instead he will say he doesn't know anything about a debt. Arthur will call him out on it, pointing out that he didn't mention a debt. The chase will then begin as normal.