When the coach passes through the area they are waiting in, Mary-Beth pretends to be suffering from amnesia. When she has all of the guard's attention, Arthur and Sean attack them with sniper rifles. Upon taking out all guards, the group gathers and Arthur loots the coach, earning them a total take of $305.00, with the player receiving $55.00.
- Laurence (coach driver) - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire
- Harry (co-driver) - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire
- Several Boles Overland guards - Killed by Arthur Morgan and Sean MacGuire
- This Companion Activity must be completed before the mission Blessed are the Peacemakers.