Events of Red Dead Redemption
When Marston first comes across Eva, she is being beaten savagely by her pimp, Mario Alcalde. Marston is given the choice to buy her freedom or leave her to continue to be beaten. Upon buying her freedom, Eva leaves the area, promising to become a nun at Las Hermanas.
Marston later visits the church to check up on Eva and finds out that Mario came back for her. The player goes to a nearby graveyard of Sepulcro to see Mario digging a grave for her. In the Journal, it is revealed that Mario killed Eva in a drunken rage. In revenge for Eva's death, Marston engages in a duel with Mario, in which Mario is gunned down, avenging Eva's death.
- Despite being buried in the graveyard of Sepulcro, Eva is not among the undead in the Undead Nightmare DLC mission "Mother Superior Blues".
Complete a task for a Stranger.
Complete 15 tasks for Strangers.
Attain 100% List in the singleplayer game completion list.