|Frank Heck||Valentine||New Hanover||On a gravestone to the northeast.|
|Otis Miller Boys||Dakota River||West Elizabeth||Southeast of the rope bridge at the Grizzlies West/Cumberland Forest is Six Point Cabin. Can be found in the back of the blue wagon slightly to the east.|
|Jack Hall Gang||Chez Porter||Ambarino||On the windowsill inside the western shack.|
|Butcher Brothers||Butcher Creek||New Hanover||On a barrel on the front porch of the southeastern-most house.|
|Flaco Hernandez||Rhodes||Lemoyne||South of the Butcher is the bank. The card can be found on the edge of the roof, accessible by ladder around back.|
|Slim Grant||Fairvale Shanty||Ambarino||On a barrel.|
|Landon Ricketts||Armadillo||New Austin||Due east of the General Store, behind the house that faces the undertaker.|
|Black Belle||Blackwater||West Elizabeth||A wrought-iron fence can be found near the riverboat company. On a crate at the foot of the fence. Only after gaining "Smoking and other Hobbies".|
|Billy Midnight||Tumbleweed||New Austin||On the platform of the windmill to the east.|
|Emmet Granger||Fort Wallace & Bluewater Marsh||New Hanover & Lemoyne|| On the table in the lean-to on the western side of the Fort. Can only be obtained from "The King's Son" until the start of "Our Best Selves".
On a table inside the abandoned house of Canebreak Manor
|Jim "Boy" Calloway||Saint Denis||Lemoyne||In a mausoleum in the northwest corner of the cemetery.|
|Bart Love||Hanging Dog Ranch||West Elizabeth||Next to the couch inside the house.|
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.