Events of Red Dead Redemption 2
Gareth is present during the Van der Linde gang's assault on the Braithwaite Manor, although he appears twice. He first appears at the entrance, warning Dutch to leave before being shot dead by him, and then again in Catherine's bedroom, where he is gunned down by either Arthur or John.
- Red Dead Redemption 2
- Given that Gareth appears twice during the assault on the Braithwaite Manor and Bartholomew is absent, it is highly likely that one of Gareth's appearances is supposed to be Bartholomew, and that it is simply a developer oversight.