Events of Red Dead Redemption 2
Later in the game, the player can hear a argument between Malloy and Moira on the second floor of the sheriff's office. Moira tells Malloy that she wants to break up their romantic relationship and insults him when he protests. Sounds of someone being strangled can then be heard in the room and Moira is not seen again; it is likely that Sheriff Malloy murdered her.
- A letter from Moira can be looted from Curtis Malloy. In this letter, Moira writes that she is increasingly worried about their affair being found out and that she wants to end their relationship, while also belittling him.