Red Dead Wiki
Advertisement
RDRstub.jpg Hey there, cowboy. This article looks a little bit small.
I reckon you could impress me by contributing to it. Don't be shy now.

Arthur: "The Foreman brothers? Well what are they doing here?"
Susan: "Well, I don't know what they've been doing here... but I can tell you what they're going to be doing here... dying."
Arthur Morgan and Susan Grimshaw.

No, No and Thrice, No is a mission in Red Dead Redemption 2.

Mission Overview[]

Susan and Arthur head to the Foreman Brothers' hideout to rescue Tilly, who has been kidnapped.

Story[]

In camp, Arthur greets Mary-Beth and the two talk while having a smoke. Susan Grimshaw interrupts the conversation and tells Arthur that Tilly has been taken by the Foreman Brothers. She grabs a revolver and tells Arthur to come with her to rescue Tilly who the Foreman Brothers took to a place called Radley's House.

When Arthur and Susan arrive at the place, Susan speaks to a lone gang member and kills him with a knife. She tells Arthur to get inside, and two more gang members are caught off guard when Arthur enters the house. Arthur then frees Tilly who is tied to a chair in a bedroom. She thanks the two for saving her and she tells them that Anthony Foreman and the gang kidnapped her. She also says that Anthony and some other gang members went out hunting. When Arthur opens the back door, Anthony and two gang members are seen fleeing on their horses. Tilly tells them to capture Anthony and bring him back alive so that she can confront him. Arthur and Susan chase the Foreman Brothers and kill the first two before Arthur lassos Anthony and brings him back to the house, while Susan takes Anthony's horse.

Back at the house, Tilly and an enraged Susan argue with Anthony and tell him to leave Tilly alone, which Anthony promises when Arthur threatens to kill him. Susan tells Arthur that it his choice whether to kill or spare Anthony before she takes Tilly back to camp.

Gold Medal Objectives[]

  • Kill both of the Foreman boys yourself during the chase.
  • Complete with at least 90% accuracy.

Deaths[]

  • Anthony Foreman (optional) - Stabbed in the stomach by Arthur if choosing to kill him.
  • Various Foreman Brothers - Killed by Susan and Arthur.

Mission Failure[]

The mission will fail if the player:

  • Assaults, kills, or abandons Susan;
  • Assaults or kills Tilly;
  • Allows Tilly to be killed by her guard;
  • Lets Anthony Foreman escape;
  • Kills Anthony Foreman before bringing him back to Tilly;
  • Destroys the wagon;
  • Kills their temporary horse;
  • Dies.

Tips[]

For this mission, the player must ride with Ms. Grimshaw in a wagon. Then the player has to chase Anthony Foreman using a commandeered leopard coat Appaloosa. After the mission is over, the Appaloosa is the only horse in the vicinity (unless the player has whistled along their horse) and the player should be advised further riding of this horse will likely result in reaching bonding level one, and will replace any temporary horse you have at base.

Video Walkthroughs[]

PS4 Version
PC Version

Trivia[]

  • At the beginning of the mission, Arthur may talk to Mary-Beth about Mary Linton and the way things were going between them; in response, Mary-Beth says, "Well, she was a fool then, Arthur", a line he later remembers during "A Fork in the Road" if his Honor is high.
  • If the player chooses to kill Anthony Foreman at the end of the mission, his bounty won't be available in the Epilogue.
  • If the mission is failed and the player retries the checkpoint, the Leopard Appaloosa may be replaced with the Blanket coat variant.
  • The dialogue between Arthur and Susan during the ride to Radley's House varies depending on whether the player has completed "Angelo Bronte, A Man of Honor". If the player does this mission after saving Jack, Susan will make no mention of Jack, but remark that Kieran Duffy has not been seen for a while. If doing this mission before saving Jack, no mention of Kieran is made and instead, Susan will point out that, considering that first Jack and now Tilly have been kidnapped, the gang has recently sustained quite some damage through the kidnappings.

Navigation[]

Red Dead Redemption 2 mission walkthroughs
Chapter 4: Saint Denis
"The Joys of Civilization""No, No and Thrice, No""Angelo Bronte, A Man of Honor""Help a Brother Out""Horsemen, Apocalypses""Fatherhood and Other Dreams""A Fine Night of Debauchery""American Fathers I""American Fathers II""Brothers and Sisters, One and All""The Gilded Cage""Urban Pleasures""Country Pursuits""Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten""Banking, The Old American Art""Lost and Not Quite Found"
Companion Activities
"Coach Robbery - Lenny Summers""Coach Robbery - Micah Bell""High and Low Finance""Hunting - Simon Pearson""Rustling - Uncle"
Chapter 1Chapter 2Chapter 3Chapter 5Chapter 6Epilogue, Part 1Epilogue, Part 2
Advertisement