Events of Red Dead Redemption 2
Peter Fotheringham can be heard preaching in Strawberry. If the player decides to greet him, he asks the player if they want to be "saved".
By 1907, Fotheringham continues as a reverend, but has become more self-aware, that he is boring and ignored by the people of Strawberry. He warns the player not to marry cold women, like his wife, and states that he is losing the will to live.
- His name is revealed in the credits.
- If the player declines his help, he will reveal that everyone runs away from him, and that his wife was the one making him do the preaching, saying "she's not a nice woman".