Pleasance is an abandoned settlement and point of interest in Red Dead Redemption 2 in the Scarlett Meadows region of the Lemoyne territory.



The town of Pleasance was founded in August 1883 and was abandoned a month later following a brutal massacre that claimed the lives of ten residents. By 1899, it has become a ghost town surrounded by an enduring mystery.

Pleasance Massacre

On September 17th 1883, Pleasance was the site of a grisly massacre that claimed the lives of ten locals. The victims were discovered either shot or stabbed in a violent manner.

The killer, or killers as the case may be, was never identified deepening the mystery surrounding the ill-fated town. The motive for the murders also remains unknown but graffiti is seen scrawled on many of the buildings.

Despite this, there is evidence that Pleasance was struck by plague. Many buildings are boarded-up and inaccessible, with signs such as "STAY OUT PLAGUE" being written on buildings, presumably as a warning not to enter in order to preserve the victims' quarantine. The easternmost house of the town also has graffiti scrawled across it; the first inscription reads "UNCLEAN SINNERS" on the wall, partially obscured by a creeping vine, while the door is scribbled "ILL WITH SINS". What connection this has with the apparent violent massacre, if any, is unknown.


  • On a table in the abandoned schoolhouse can be found Otis Miller and the Boy from New York. On a desk is the Cigarette Card for Fountain Pen - 1884 - Lewis Waterman. On the mantle is Ginseng Elixir.
  • To the northwest of the schoolhouse is a barn. On the northeast side of the barn in the bushes in a crate that has the Cigarette Card for Lillian Powell.
  • A dreamcatcher can be found far to the northeast, across the border near where the roads converge.
  • A large dead Snake can be found in a tree south of here.
  • The town has much in common with Boston, Ohio, otherwise known as Helltown. The church in Boston is almost identical to the one in Pleasance, and both were rumoured to have been abandoned due to Satanists.
    • There was also rumoured to be a chemical spill in Boston, causing animals to change in size and behaviour; the most famous rumoured animal said to be lurking in Boston was a giant python. Similarly, there is a giant snake outside of Pleasance.

Known graves

These gravestones are written as follows:

  • Leora Yeatman

Killed by Gunshot

September 1883

Aged 38 yrs

A dear wife & Mother

  • Jessie Yeatman


September 1883

Aged 14 Yrs

A tragic loss of a beautiful soul

  • Asa Hawson

Found Murdered

Sept. 1883

Aged 34 Years

Beloved Mother

  • Amelia Curle

Dead of gunshot to the head

Sept. 1883

Aged 66 yrs

  • Reginald Yeatman

Killed by Gunshot

September 1883

Aged 43 Yrs

Loved Father & Husband

  • Jimmy Hawson

Killed by Knife Wound

Sept. 17th 1883

Age 15 years

May He Find Eternal Peace in Heaven

  •  Daniel Curley

Had His Life Taken

On Sept. 17th


  • Glen Yeatman

Killed by Knife Wound

September 1883

Aged 15 Yrs

Taken Too Soon

  • Curtis Baines

Born 1823

Murdered September 1883

His Love Has Taken 

From Him by Hate

  •  Edmund Tobin

Born July 1854

Killed by Gunshot

September 1883

Aged 29 Yrs



Points of Interests in Red Dead Redemption 2
Abandoned ChurchAbandoned Trading PostBarrel RiderBolger GladeBraithwaites’ SecretBrush FireCircus WagonsCrashed AirshipDefaced GraveDonkey LadyFace in CliffFaces in TreesFlying MachineFossilized ManFrozen SettlerGiant RemainsGray’s SecretHermit WomanHidden TunnelJesuit MissionaryMammothManmade MutantMeditating MonkMeteor HouseMeteoriteMysterious Hill HomeNative BurialObeliskOil DerrickOld TombOld World ScriptsPagan RitualPhonographPleasanceRegister RockSerpent MoundSperm Whale BonesStrange StatuesStrange Statues (Cave Painting)Tiny ChurchTrading PostTrail Trees (I)Trail Trees (II)Trail Trees (III)Trail Trees (IV)Warped TreeWhale BonesWickiupWithered Arm
AmbarinoLemoyneNew AustinNew HanoverWest ElizabethLocations
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.