Events of Red Dead Online
Events of Red Dead Redemption 2
In the epilogue, after the mission "Motherhood", Neely's store can be visited by John Marston, who can purchase provisions, tonics, accessories for hunting and fishing, horse supplies, ammunition as well as a selection of guns and rifles.
Events of Red Dead Redemption
Although Neely himself is not encountered in Red Dead Redemption, his shop is still present under his name in Blackwater.
- By 1911, S. M. Neely Ship Chandler and Grocer is instead run by Norris Laskey, implying that Neely had lost or sold his store.