Murder's Committed:

Does anyone think the should list all of the murders that gang has committed? Mitt Campbell (talk) 15:26, October 30, 2018 (UTC)

The comment above, yeah I don't think you can list all the people (npcs or otherwise) they killed as some are determinate. What I do question is does this mean that they the Pinkertons and Bereau set out to destroy the gang, yet theres enough survives some of whom have committed mass crimes in the game. So does that mean they technically failed in bringing the complete gang to justice, or do we only count Dutch and the major characters in the gang as their targets?

Susan Grimshaw, Founding Member?

So Tilly asks Arthur, in the cutscene before their first dominoes game/ her Camp Item Request, if Ms. Grimshaw has always been a sour person.  Arthur laughs and replies that he "ain't quite old enough to know"; when she asks him if she's been like that as long as he's known her, he agrees.  It's not explicit, but I took this as suggesting Ms. Grimshaw ran with Dutch and Hosea (possibly at the same time she was Dutch's lover) some time before the gang found Arthur.  The fact that Arthur relates his knowledge to his age, and not to his meeting her, makes me suspect he sees her as another familal figure, much in the same way he views Dutch and Hosea.  Does this track, or is it too flimsy a premise?  Is there possibly other ambient dialogue clarifying her when and how she joined up?   Macmanius (talk) 19:53, December 6, 2018 (UTC)


Just a question, not particularly something that important, but iv'e noticed that no "Decased Icons" are displayed for the memebers of the Van Der Linde gang. Is something we are going to change or is it left off for spoiler purposes, which I assume it is. I'm just curious and would be happy to edit them in but I wanted to check for once since it's quite a important addition. Also as second question would you like me to remove the occupation of each memeber I added but I filled them all in becuase someone had began to list the roles of Dutch, Hosea and Athur so I thought I would do the rest. Any answers would be greatly appriated, I'm trying to inteact more with my fellow editors now, anyway thanks a lot!

First sign your posts on a talk page. As for deceased icons, why? The table lists the deceased with the word deceased. An icon would be redunant and imo useless. As for the occupation, I say leave it. --Revan's Exile (talk) 22:37, January 14, 2019 (UTC)

We're gonna remove the cross/deceased icon anyways with time, as well as the status, so no; no need to add the former. -- User:Raziel Reaper (Talk To MeEdits ) 09:39, January 15, 2019 (UTC)
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.