After the gang are attacked by Pinkertons, Dutch realizes that the gang need to move and, because they can no longer go any further east, they must go north instead. Arthur and Charles ride to Roanoke Ridge (or by canoe if the player wishes) and eventually arrive at Beaver Hollow. After stealthily dispatching members of the Murfree gang who are outside the cave, Arthur and Charles then deal with those in the cave. After finding a girl named Meredith who had been captured and abused by the Murfrees, Arthur takes her back to her home in Annesburg while Charles goes back to the others to let them know where the new camp is.
As the gang are setting up the new camp, Uncle returns with a drunk Molly O'Shea. She claims that she ratted out the gang to the Pinkertons and taunts Dutch. Before she can say any more, Susan shoots her in the stomach with a shotgun, killing her, before asking Bill and Pearson to burn the body.
Gold Medal Objectives
- Deliver Meredith to her mother within 2 minutes.
- Get 15 headshots.
- Complete with at least 85% accuracy.
- Complete the mission without taking any health items.
- Molly O'Shea - Killed by Susan Grimshaw after confessing that she betrayed the gang.
- Various members of the Murfree Brood - killed by Arthur and Charles in order to establish a camp in the area.
- In the third trailer for Redemption 2, the scene featured in this mission where Dutch questions Arthur's loyalty is shown, but in it, Arthur does not look ill and instead has the same appearance as he does pre-illness, when he is healthy. This was likely done to avoid spoilers.
Completing this mission and chapter contributes toward the following Trophies/Achievements:
Complete Chapter 5
Earn 70 Gold Medals in Story missions.
Attain 100% Completion.