And when Jack says “Uncle was old when I was a kid” Johns response clearly refers to himself knowning Uncle when he was a child. Uncle is clearly older than John and it would be foolish to speculate that John could have known Uncle as a child, but it’s not unreasonable to assume a young John knew Uncle considering it is mentioned numerous times that John was recruited by Dutch as a child. Uncle could have been there considering how often he is referred to as being around a young Arthur, John, and even by Bill who was recruited around 1893

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.