Now, I own Red Dead Redemption (not in th metaphorical sense; I literally own a copy of the game), and I've played Grand Theft Auto IV, and personally much prefer Red Dead. I really wanted to buy it after watching a few videos on YouTube, and I think its brilliant. I have to say... Grand Theft Auto never really grabbed my attention, even after a few hours playing it. Maybe the Red Dead setting, and the gameplay that brings, makes it more appealing to me, I don't know... but what do you think?

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.