Hey guys,

I couldn't help but notice that there is a big plot hole/continuity error between the original RDR & RDR 2. In RDR 1, John mentions that he parted from Dutch's gang after they left him to die after a robbery went south in 1905, however the epilogue of RDR 2 insinuates that he's been away from the gang since it all fell apart in 1899? I can hardly imagine him going back to the gang for another 6 years after they all turned on him and Arthur like that... Anyone have an explanation? Or is this just a massive oversight by Rockstar?

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.