Valuables

Valuables can be looted from dead characters, chests, and many other places in the game. They can only be sold to a Fence, but some are also used in crafting. They can also be donated to the camp.

Notes

• Some unique items may have special traits which are not clearly specified in-game, so it is recommended caution before selling or donating it.

• While some items may respawn despite being "unique", others cannot be retrieved back nor acquired again once sold or donated without recurring to cheats and exploits. Usually, this happens with unique items which are mailed as a reward to the player, like the infamous Quartz Chunk from Deborah MacGuiness. That means that if an unreplaceable item is necessary to a particular crafting, it leaves the player no other option than to start a new game for 100% completion.
• On the other hand, some unique items which respawn cannot be sold nor donated if re-acquired by the player, therefore shall permanently occupy space in the satchel for the rest of the game.

Incomplete List of Valuables

Item	Price	Note
Abalone Shell Fragment	NA	"This is a unique item." Necessary for crafting the Bison Horn Talisman. Found at an abandoned yellow house near the Rhodes butcher. Further properties unknown. Respawns after some in-game days.
Ammolite	$25.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Ancient Arrowhead	$10.00	"This is a unique item." Doubles the player's stamina when bow is equipped. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Ancient Necklace	$20.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Ancient Viking Comb	$50.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated. Note: The item will disappear from the satchel after the player has completed the mission "Red Dead Redemption".
Catherine's Brooch	$25.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Charles Châtenay's Sketch	$2.20 ($4.23 St. Denis)	"This is a unique item." Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Emerald	$50.00	Received from the mission "He's British, of Course". Further properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Female Fertility Statue	$25.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Found in a lock box at the Roadside Brothel. Respawns after a few in-game days.
Fertility Statue	$25.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Found hid in a chimney at the Old Bacchus Place. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Fluorite	$25.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Gator Eggs	$2.50	Found in many nests around where alligators spawn. The Trapper can also buy these. Necessary for the stranger mission strand "Duchesses and other Animals".
Gold Bar	$500.00	Found in various hidden areas and lock boxes. Most don't respawn. However, there is one gold bar that respawns around once every 1-2 in-game weeks.
Gold Earring	$2.00	Lootable and also found inside drawers. Necessary for crafting the Boar Tusk Talisman.
Gold Ingot	$300.00	Found in many places and lock boxes around the map. Respawns after some in-game days.
Gold Nugget	$25.00	Lootable and also found in many places and lock boxes around the map. Respawns after some in-game days.
Gold Jointed Bracelet	$7.00	Necessary for crafting the Alligator Tooth Talisman.
Gold Pendant Necklace	$8.00	Lootable item.
Gold Plate Buckle	$3.00	Lootable item.
Gold Pocket Watch	$10.00	Lootable and also found in some places and lock boxes around the map. Can be used by the player as a personal watch.
Gold Wedding Ring	$5.00	Lootable item.
Gold Shield	NA (cannot be sold)	"This is a unique item." It can be taken from above the fireplace in the first room on left side during the mission "Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern". Properties unknown. Once looted, it cannot be sold and will remain in the player's satchel for the rest of the game.
Gold Tooth	$1.00	Lootable item.
Jimmy Brook's Pen	$10.00	"This is a unique item." Obtainable only if the player spares Jimmy Brooks. Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated. Note: The item will disappear from the satchel after the player has completed the mission "Red Dead Redemption".
Large Jewelry Bag	$50.00	Found in many drawers and lock boxes around the map. Respawns after some in-game days.
Meteorite	$30.00	"This is a unique item." Reduces the player's exposition damage to hot environments by 10%. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Native American Ring	$10.00	"This is a unique item." Looted from a random encounter around Fort Wallace and Beaver Hollow. Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Necklace	$2.00	Lootable item.
Old Brass Compass	NA	Necessary for crafting the Raven Claw Talisman. Found at Francis Sinclair's cabin after completing his side-mission "Geology for Beginners". Respawns after some in-game days. Used exclusively for crafting the talisman and cannot be sold if re-acquired.
Penelope's Bracelet	$75.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Arthur can accept it as reward for completing the stranger side-mission strand "The Course of True Love". Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Pearl Necklace	$4.00	Lootable item.
Platinum Band	$7.00	Lootable item.
Platinum Chain Necklace	$10.00	NA
Platinum Earring	$3.00	Lootable and also found in drawers and chests around the map.
Platinum Engraved Buckle	$5.00	Lootable and also found in chests around the map.
Platinum Pocket Watch	$12.00	Lootable and also found in some places around the map. Can be used by the player as a personal watch.
Platinum Spring Bracelet	$9.00	Lootable. Rich females in Saint Denis.
Quartz Chunk	$10.00	Reward from Deborah MacGuiness for mailing the first location of a dinosaur bone. Necessary for crafting the Bear Claw Talisman. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Reutlinger Pocket Watch	$155.00	"This is a unique item." Can be used by the player as a personal watch. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Rock Statue	$50.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Shrunken Head	$15.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Found inside a bottle on the altar of a small voodoo shrine at Lakay.
Silver Chain Bracelet	$5.00	Found in some places and lock boxes around the map. Necessary for crafting the Bear Claw Talisman. Respawns after some in-game days.
Silver Clamp Buckle	$1.00	NA
Silver Earring	$1.00	Lootable and also found inside drawers and chests around the map. Necessary for crafting the Bison Horn Talisman.
Silver Emblem Ring	$3.00	Lootable item.
Silver Locket Necklace	$6.00	NA
Silver Pocket Watch	$8.00	Lootable and also found in some places around the map. Can be used by the player as a personal watch.
Skull Statue	$75.00	"This is a unique item." Properties unknown. Cannot be re-acquired once sold or donated.
Small Jewelry Bag	$25.00	Found in some places and lock boxes around the map. Respawns after some in-game days.
Silver Tooth	$0.70	Lootable item.
Wedding Ring	$7.00	Lootable item.